Sherwood Forester

Issue 4 - April 2004

 

 

 

 

Editorial comment

 

Hello again and welcome to our fourth issue of the Sherwood Forester.

If you cast your minds back to our second issue, we reproduced an article from a US TV Guide published on the 7th July 1956, “The British Hopalong”.  At that time we were unable to include a copy of the photograph of Richard Greene on his yacht in Southampton Water that accompanied the article.  Our thanks go to Lucy Carpenter who has obtained an original copy of the magazine and now with a little bit of editorial licence we have included it as our cover image for this issue. 

Also in this issue we include the third and final part of Steve Winders’ ‘Childhood Heroes’.  Our thanks go to Steve for allowing us to reproduce the article in its entirety; our hope is that you have all enjoyed it as much as we have.

Unfortunately due to external commitments, we have been unable to include details of plans for the “50th Anniversary Celebrations”.  Sincere apologies, however we will do our best to put the suggestions on the website shortly.

 

In this Issue

 

A REPLY

To Steve Winders’ “Childhood Heroes: Robin Hood”, Part 2

Anna’s thoughts on Steve Winders' 'Childhood Heroes' article.  Here she looks at Part 2 in which he writes about our very own 'The Adventures of Robin Hood'.

 

Childhood Heroes

The third and final part of Steve Winders’ ‘Childhood Heroes’ article.  Here Steve examines Richard Greene’s final performance as Robin Hood in the 1960 feature film ‘The Sword of Sherwood Forest’. 

 

Episode Review – The Highlander

Lucy Carpenter starts a series of episode reviews, which concentrates on the four episodes that feature the Scottish Outlaw, Duncan of Stoneykirk.

 

A Bull’s-Eye for Robin Hood!

Once again we take a look at another article reproduced from a US TV Guide circa 1957.

 

Trivia – Marx Playsets and Figures

Far from trivial, this issue sees Ralph Cooper write about his collection of Marx playsets and figures with accompanying images.

 

Letters (Emails) To The Editors

Unfortunately due to external commitments we have been unable to include any letters (emails) this time, please accept our sincere apologies but it will be back for our next issue.

 

 

A REPLY
To Steve Winders’ “Childhood Heroes: Robin Hood”, Part 2

 

Or perhaps just an opportunity to write about my favourite subject – the characters in “The Adventures”, and, most importantly, the hero himself…

 

So what was Richard Greene’s Robin really like?  He was variously described as “cheerful and resourceful” (by Jeffrey Richards in his book “Swordsmen of the Screen”), and as “serious-minded and officer-like“ (by Professor Stephen Knight, a leading Robin Hood expert).  Perhaps the authors just happened to watch different episodes?  There is, of course, some truth in these descriptions, but it is certainly not the whole truth.  As Steve said, Richard Greene’s Robin was a returning soldier, like the real life heroes of the Second World War; but at the same time he belonged among the characters of the costume adventure tradition.  Steve mentions Greene’s “swashbuckling credentials” – his roles in the early 1950s Hollywood films.   There were several – not just in “Captain Scarlett” and “Lorna Doone”, but also in “The Desert Hawk” (an Oriental adventure), “The Black Castle”(a Gothic horror story), and the romantic drama “Shadow of the Eagle”. And this (perhaps unlikely) character, part-WW2 officer type, and part-swashbuckling hero, turned out to be very successful, as we all know…

 

What about the “close resemblance” between Richard Greene and Richard Todd?  Both were good looking, with short dark hair – and that is, I think, where the resemblance ended. Compared to Richard Todd, Richard Greene was considerably taller, and strongly built.  And the “clean shaven, clean cut” image was not always there, either; Richard Greene’s Robin frequently appeared - in disguise - with a beard and moustache, and even unshaven in some early episodes.  And while Todd was pleasant looking, Greene had true star quality and a charismatic screen presence that made a lasting impression on the young viewers. 

 

I do not think that Greene’s “portrayal of Robin Hood was quite close to Todd’s”.  It is true that his Robin was “an experienced and self assured character”, but also – a lot more complex one, and not just because of the length of the series. Steve writes, “Surely it is not just a coincidence that an older actor was cast as Robin”. I believe it is quite possible that Richard Greene was offered the part despite his age, and not because of it.  “Master Robin”, just returned from the Holy Land in the first episode, was probably meant to be a few years younger than Richard Greene – most likely about thirty, at an age when he could have both youthful vigour and wisdom of experience. Robin’s age is not specifically mentioned in the film, but in the episode “The Elixir of Youth” he is described as looking “not a day over thirty”. Only later in the series, as the actors grew older, so did the characters, and some indirect references to age and the passing of time were written into the story.

 

As Steve says, Richard Greene’s Robin is “a seasoned campaigner” – with the war experience behind him that had left its mark, and made him the man he was.  But “a father or favourite uncle figure”?  Obviously, Steve presents a boy’s point of view here... This (female) viewer remembers Robin as a chivalrous figure of a champion and protector, who managed to be at the same time reassuring and exciting, with a hint of mystery in his unknown past; a man of action and feeling, strong, but sensitive - a true Romantic hero, in fact.  Robin’s costume was probably significant - the white shirt (rather impractical in the forest) is associated not just with the swashbuckling aristocrats, but also - with Romantic poets, who followed the greatest real life Romantic hero of them all, Lord Byron.

 

Richard Greene’s Robin was a hero with intelligence, personal warmth and humour, and with what has been described as “matinee idol good looks”. But, to me, he was also a character with implied “hidden depths”, intensity of feelings, perhaps even emotional vulnerability. Greene had a considerable acting experience beyond the costume adventure genre.  His Robin Hood character developed in the course of the series into a timeless portrait of a man of action and leader, always conscious of the pressures and responsibilities of command, who makes mistakes and shows uncertainty, and, occasionally, weariness.

 

I do not think that there is any doubt about Robin’s social and intellectual superiority over his men.  He sincerely believes in egalitarian ideals, and is even described as “a traitor to his class”.  But with his confidence, knowledge, eloquence, wit and charm, he could not be anything else but a nobleman, with all the benefits of an upper class background and education.

 

Of the band members, only Will Scarlet could be considered Robin’s intellectual equal (that is, the original Will Scarlet, as played by Ronald Howard; Paul Eddington’s performance seemed to me less convincing). And, outside the band, Lady Marian and Friar Tuck – Robin often turns to them for advice and support. Steve describes the band members as “strong and able characters”; I would add, also well trained by their leader, who did not just teach them fighting skills, but moral values, and a certain standard of conduct.

 

I do not believe that Little John behaved irrationally because the plot demanded it – irrationality was part of his personality. He was a good fighter, but not very bright, and often impulsive.  But he did become a dependable second-in-command in the end.  And I would never describe Friar Tuck as sanctimonious.  He was a man of principle and a sincere Christian believer, but with a wonderful sense of humour and irony, and some very human weaknesses.

 

The Lady Marian character certainly reflected the changes in the role of women after the Second World War, but we must not forget that Marian, dressed as a page, fought Robin (and almost defeated him) in one of the traditional ballads, long before the age of women’s equality.  The Sheriff was secretly in love with Marian; that was why she was never suspected of consorting with outlaws.  And no matter how sensible the Sheriff (and his schemes) appeared, he was always outwitted by Robin in the end.  The Deputy Sheriff was charming, but also shrewd and merciless.  He was “the devil you don’t know,” probably a worse villain than the Sheriff, and a more formidable opponent for Robin.

 

I wholeheartedly agree with Steve’s assessment that the series conveyed a “combination of light heartedness and deeper meaning”.  It also successfully switched between drama and comedy, often in one and the same episode.  As to Richard Greene’s performance, I believe that he created the most complex, memorable, interesting, and best acted Robin Hood character in all the film and TV versions, before or since.

 

There will be no reply to Part 3 of Steve’s article, simply because I could not find anything to disagree with!  Although I noticed that Steve did not address the question why “Sword of Sherwood Forest” proved disappointing to so many viewers; it would probably require a separate article.  Perhaps we could try and answer that question together?  I would like to invite our readers to share their opinions and observations on the subject of “Sword of Sherwood Forest - what went wrong, and why?” (A. F).

 

 

CHILDHOOD HEROES : ROBIN HOOD - PART THREE 

 

Steve Winders recalls the adventures of Robin Hood from the films and television programmes of the 1950s. In this third and final part he completes his exploration of the long running television series starring Richard Greene and examines Greene’s final performance as Robin Hood in the 1960 feature film ‘Sword of Sherwood Forest’.

 

 

The television series ‘The Adventures of Robin Hood’, made by Sapphire Productions, was first shown on British and American television in 1955. It was filmed at the small Nettlefold Studios in Walton–On–Thames and in nearby woods!

 

The first few episodes, which introduced the characters and set the scene, were written and directed by Ralph Smart. He wrote and directed several other episodes in the first two series before going on to produce another adventure series called ‘The Buccaneers’ for Sapphire and then to work as executive producer on ‘The Adventures of William Tell’ for I.T.C. and National Telefilm Associates. Other writers included the American film writer Ring Lardner Junior, who came to Britain to escape the notorious ‘Mc Carthy Witch Hunt’ in the U.S.A. After his return to America, Lardner later won an Academy Award for his screenplay for the film M.A.S.H. Another blacklisted American writer was the British born Ian McClellan Hunter, who had emigrated to the U.S.A. as a teenager. He had collaborated with Lardner on film screenplays in Hollywood and he wrote episodes for ‘Robin Hood’ using the pseudonym ‘Samuel B. West.’

 

Remarkably, the influence of disaffected American writers can be quite clearly recognised in the stories from ‘The Adventures of Robin Hood’. Obviously many stories focused on freedom and repression as one might expect in a programme about Robin Hood, but several were quite direct in attacking issues relating to coercion and betrayal. In one episode, the Sheriff persuades a non-regular member of Robin’s band to betray him in the public interest. As Robin Hood fought against injustice for the poor of medieval England, so the television series rejected intolerance in nineteen fifties America. Most young viewers were no doubt blissfully unaware of the ‘Mc Carthy Witch Hunt’ in America, but this did not affect their enjoyment of the episodes or their understanding of the broader moral issues they posed.

 

The series also provided useful experience for several British film directors. Lindsay Anderson, who went on to direct ‘This Sporting Life’, ‘If ’ and ‘O Lucky Man’, directed five episodes. Terence Fisher, who directed several of Hammer’s best horror films, directed ten episodes in the first two series and Don Chaffey who directed ‘Jason and The Argonauts’, directed six episodes.

 

Despite its enormous popularity, the programme was produced on a low budget and it often shows. Each episode was completed in four and a half days! Nevertheless much ingenuity went into making the series and the pioneering work of experienced art director Peter Proud is a good example of this. He devised a new method of set construction which helped to save both time and money and has consequently been widely copied ever since. In traditional film making, studio technicians built huge sets and then lined the cameras up on them for each sequence. To cut out delays and speed up production, Proud constructed large items of scenery, such as a baronial fireplace, a staircase or a serf’s hut and mounted them on wheels so that they could be quickly moved into position. Items could be used over and over again, but differently arranged to become completely different sets and the cameras didn’t need to be moved at all in studio work! 

 

Given its enormous popularity, it is not surprising that the series spawned a huge merchandising operation. I myself had a ‘Robin Hood’ outfit; a ‘Robin Hood’ bow and arrows, with rubber suckers on the end; a ‘Robin Hood’ story book, with pictures from the series and a whole band of small plastic toy soldier sized figures of Robin and his merry men. The best of these were made by Britain’s Toys in their ‘Herald Models’ range. Their Robin and Marian figures bore a remarkable likeness to their television counterparts. I also had some Lone Star toy figures of the merry men and some that were given free with ‘Kellogg’s Sugar Smacks’, which I think were made by Crescent Toys. As Robin Hood is a national hero and could not be copyrighted by Sapphire Films, much merchandising was unlicensed, which explains why there was such a large number of products and why several toy companies produced similar models.

 

A memorable feature of ‘The Adventures of Robin Hood’ was its famous title song. Sung by Dick James over the end credits of each episode, the song became a Top Twenty hit for both James and Gary Miller in January 1956. It was regularly requested on the radio programme ‘Children’s Favourites’ for many years. I had a ‘78’ copy of James’ version, which also featured ‘The Ballad of Davy Crockett’.

 

Although the series ended in 1958, new episodes were still being screened in many ITV regions until the early sixties, as most of the ITV companies had not commenced broadcasting until 1956 or later. Even this was not the end of Richard Greene’s ‘Robin Hood’ though. The series was regularly repeated throughout the sixties in Britain and for much longer in many other countries. I remember that Granada TV in the north of England showed it three times a week in the mid sixties. Greene himself went on to play Robin in a feature film ‘The Sword of Sherwood Forest’, made by Hammer Films in 1960. This was shot in Ireland and was co-produced by Richard Greene and Sidney Cole. Cole had also worked as associate producer on the TV series, which had been produced by Hannah Weinstein. 

 

The film was directed by Terence Fisher, who was no stranger to Robin Hood, having directed ten episodes of the first two television series. However the only regular actor from the series to appear was Richard Greene. Little John was played by Nigel Green, who had appeared as Fertog ‘the Bear’, a similar character to Little John, in ‘The Adventures of William Tell’, one of the many programmes which tried to emulate the success of  ‘Robin Hood’. Friar Tuck was played by Niall Mac Ginnis and the Sheriff of Nottingham by Peter Cushing. Other leading parts were played by Oliver Reed, Richard Pasco, Edwin Richfield and Derren Nesbitt. The film told a new tale of Robin Hood and not the whole story of his outlawry and subsequent pardon by Richard the Lionheart, as the previous films had done. Robin was still an outlaw at the conclusion of the film, just as he had been at the end of each television episode and the way was obviously left open for further films.

 

 Filmed on a much larger budget than the television programme, but a small budget as films go, ‘The Sword of Sherwood Forest’ enjoyed limited success in the cinema. This was attributed by several critics to a change of cast from the television series and this is probably fair comment. The series was well served by a team of excellent actors, who clearly enjoyed their work. Despite a fine performance as the Sheriff, Peter Cushing was following too closely on the heels of Alan Wheatley, who had made the part his own for four years and was still being seen regularly in the role on television. To his credit, Cushing avoided playing the part as Wheatley had done, even wearing a long dark wig to make his appearance quite different. In real life the two actors bore a slight resemblance to each other.

 

Sarah Branch, as a blonde glamorous Marian, much more in keeping with the ‘Hammer Film’ style of leading lady, compared most unfavourably with Bernadette O’Farrell and Patricia Driscoll, who had converted the character to an action heroine and a popular role model for girls. Other actors did well, but they were not the familiar faces who had come to be Little John and Friar Tuck for so many viewers. The ‘real’ Robin Hood was there, but he was surrounded by strangers. The lukewarm box office reception meant that no further films were made with Richard Greene as Robin, although Hammer made another Robin Hood film in 1968, with Barrie Ingham in the title role. 

 

And so the adventures of my boyhood version of Robin Hood came to an end. There have been subsequent successful versions of course and I have probably seen them all, but none carry the authority, conviction and sheer exuberance of the Richard Todd and Richard Greene versions, which in my opinion captured the optimistic spirit of Robin Hood better than any others. Thanks to these, the 1950s was the decade when Robin Hood enjoyed his greatest popularity in the twentieth century.

 

 

 

Episode Review – The Highlander

 

THE HIGHLANDER, HIGHLAND FLING, THE BAGPIPPER, and

THE PARTING GUEST

 

The above episodes are a four part series, which brings together the Scottish Outlaw Duncan of Stoneykirk and our favorite English Outlaw Robin Hood. The combination of the two “outlaws” makes for very entertaining viewing and an interesting contrast of the English Outlaw and the Scottish Outlaw.

 

GUEST STARS:

 

HUGH MCDERMOTT – DUNCAN OF STONEYKIRK

WILLOGHBY GRAY  - OTTO

 

SCREENWRITER – ERIC HEATH (RING LARDNER, JR)

DIRECTOR – RALPH SMART

 

STRANGE TALES ARE TOLD OF ROBIN HOOD,

BUT THE STRANGEST ARE ALL OF THE LOT

WHEN HE MET WILD DUNCAN

A VERY CANNY SCOT

 

Robin, Little John and Friar Tuck are talking over plans for an ambush of a delivery of wine when their meeting is interrupted by the audacious appearance of Duncan of Stoneykirk, and his brash announcement that they are too late for the ambush. He then proceeds to show them the barrels of wine that he has already procured, quite to their amazement.  Friar Tuck admonishes Duncan for listening to their secret plans; he tells him, “these are plans that we could get hanged for”, to which Duncan retorts, “Who would hang anyone for robbing an Englishman?”  Thus commences the introduction of Duncan of Stoneykirk, an “outlaw” none the likes of which Robin or his men had ever seen.

 

Robin is bemused by his uninvited guest, and when Marian arrives for a visit Robin is concerned for her safety and wants her to leave before Duncan sees her; unfortunately, Duncan has already spotted the “Fair Lassie” and is eager for an introduction.  Marian, upset by what she perceives as a cool welcome from Robin, and perhaps feeling a little neglected, is flattered by Duncan’s attention.  She is intrigued by his stories of the Highlands and Highland women; all the while Robin is curious of Duncan’s true intentions, and is becoming concerned with his obvious attraction to Marian. When Duncan asks Marian if she likes to hunt, and she eagerly says yes, they make plans for the next morning to go hunting for boar.  Robin tries to put a stop to the plans, insisting it is too dangerous for Marian, and a little power struggle ensues.  Marian may still be feeling hurt by what she perceives as a not so friendly greeting from Robin, she isn’t understanding his true concern for her safety, and agrees to go hunting with Duncan as a way of making Robin jealous.  Duncan declares that she is a “Fine Scottish Lass except for an accident in geography.”  He has been sizing up the situation for his own advantage; he knows of Robin’s reputation, his strengths, his leadership qualities, but perhaps what Duncan is really looking for is Robin’s weakness.  He realizes that Robin’s weakness is Marian and he will use this weakness to distract Robin so that he will get what he really came to Sherwood Forest in search of.

 

“It takes an outlaw to meet an outlaw”, that is Duncan’s explanation to Robin when asked why he is really in Sherwood Forest.  Robin’s innate ability to discern between honesty and falsehoods gives him reason to be suspicious of the Scottish Outlaw’s pretence for wanting to meet Robin and solicit him and his men to come to the Highlands to help Duncan and his “outlaws” fight the unjust King William the Lion, who has turned on his people and is now allying himself with Prince John.  Robin announces to him that “my men and I are not for hire”.

 

Duncan’s plan to lure Robin away from the camp worked, he knew that Robin would come out to find Marian and that he would trap him and get what he really came after.  Robin would never let his guard down, his ability to size up situations and predict danger has always made him the strong leader that he is, but the “weakness” that Duncan knew, Robin’s love and concern for Marian, made him the target of Duncan’s trickery.  Duncan underestimated Robin’s ability and when Robin was able to free himself and get back to camp, he found Duncan in the storage cave retrieving what he had come to Sherwood Forest in search of – the Dalgar Dirk.  Confronted by Robin and his men Duncan explained his fierce loyalty to the people of the Highlands and his desire to take back the Dalgar Dirk – a sword, which Robin and his men had managed to “take possession of”.  Duncan tells how King William of Scotland had sent the sword as a gift to Prince John and how the courier had been waylaid in Sherwood Forest and it never made its way to Prince John.  Duncan explains the history and symbolism of the Dalgar Dirk and the importance of how it could “decide the history of Scotland”.  Our chivalrous outlaw returns the sword to Duncan, only after he had closely examined the handle and discovered inside the handle were eight black pearls. Robin takes his share of the pearls and Duncan leaves Sherwood Forest amicably.

 

Duncan of Stoneykirk is loud, overbearing, and abrasive but underneath all these harsh judgements you get the distinct feeling, which I’m sure that Robin sensed, that for all his faults, he had a very deep loyalty to his fellow “Highlander Outlaws”.  And Robin respected this loyalty – Duncan was fighting the same battle in Scotland that Robin and his men were fighting in England, there was a definite kinship.  As with all the episodes there is always the message of hope, respect and loyalty.

 

Eric Heath (Ring Lardner, Jr) created a very entertaining character in the form of Duncan of Stoneykirk, so much so that he was brought back for three more episodes – so the Story of Duncan of Stoneykirk, the Wild Scotsman shall be continued… 

 

In the next instalment entitled “Highland Fling”, Robin makes a journey to Scotland and we shall see how he fares in Duncan’s territory.

 

Lucy Carpenter

 

A Bull’s-Eye for Robin Hood!

 

       

An early article reproduced from the Chicago Daily TV Week, 1st December 1956.

 

If there’s a success formula for TV, “The Adventures of Robin Hood” has found it.  A British import with a relatively unknown cast, the series reaped high ratings when it was premiered last year and is still drubbing its opposition.

 

It is slotted early [6:30 pm Mondays, channel 2] to attract the kids, but it has scored just as heavily with adults.  Not only that, its 12th century English hero is also thrilling viewers in Australia, Puerto Rico, Mexico and Japan.  How come?

 

For one thing, “Robin Hood” is an accurate and colourful slice of medieval life.  Researchers have scoured libraries and museums to make sure that the costumes and scenery are authentic.  The actors are carefully trained to wear their costumes as though they were born to them, to wield awkward weapons with ease and to perform effortlessly the athletic feats required by the script.

 

Even the extras are coached in swordsmanship by Gabriel Toyne, an expert on medieval arms and armor and one of the few Englishmen to earn the title, “Maitre d’Armes”.

 

Richard Greene, who plays Robin, is able to combine the timeless qualities of a legendary hero with the intimate details of everyday life.  Now in his mid-thirties, he draws on three decades of stage experience.  He got his first part, a walk-on, when he was three years old and learned his craft in the tough school of the touring repertory company.

 

The script writers, realising that audiences soon tire of familiar faces, have cleverly rationed the appearances of supporting actors.  Maid Marian [Bernadette O’Farrell], for example turns up frequently, but does not appear in every episode.  Ian Hunter, who plays her uncle, hardly has a chance to wear out his welcome.

 

Authenticity, credibility, and humanity – this, then, is the “Robin Hood” formula.  And judging from the multitude of contented viewers, it’s a rousing success.

 

(Our thanks go to Elaine Brulinski who did the research to unearth this article, and to Lucy Carpenter who provided the image from her personal collection)


 

Trivia – Marx Playsets and Figures

 

Louis Marx & Co. Inc. manufactured all sorts of playsets and plastic figures back in the 1950's. Those of you that are of that vintage will remember well the plastic toy soldiers, plastic farmyard animals, plastic zoo animals, plastic cowboys and indians etc etc - the list is endless. Without doubt Louis Marx was the largest manufacturer of these playsets and was based in the USA.  Among the multitude of playsets, one of the most popular was the "Robin Hood Set" consisting of a tin castle, and plastic accessories including a full set of Merry Men and the Sheriff's Men.

 

 

In 1955 Louis Marx commissioned two sets of Robin Hood figures which included the 5 character figures of Robin Hood, Maid Marian, Friar Tuck, Little John and the Sheriff of Nottingham. One set was in 60 mm and the other in 54 mm. At the same time he commissioned a second set of 60mm character figures which was licensed by Official Films Inc, the owners of the TV series. These figures were reasonable likenesses of Richard Greene, Bernadette O'Farrell, Alexander Gauge, Archie Duncan and Alan Wheatley.  The two 60mm sets sold were virtually identical except for the five character figures and the printing on the box.  It would appear that to save paying license fees or whatever, not many of the Richard Greene sets were produced in preference to the less costly generic sets.

 

The TV series plastic figures were much more detailed and considered by many to be among the best, if not "the" best, produced by Marx.  So due to the high quality and lack of quantity, the Richard Greene TV series figures are now highly prized by Marx collectors.  To-day you would expect to pay in excess of $ US 100 each for the TV series character figures; the last Maid Marian to sell on ebay went for over $ US 200. They are most certainly increasing in value all the time.

 

 

A box, which is just plain old brown cardboard with green print and depicting a stylised drawing of Richard Greene's face, is worth in the vicinity of $ US 200 - yes, empty.  This makes a full set (castle, men, accessories and box) worth in excess of $ US 1,000. A long way above the original price in 1956 of about $ 6 or $ 7.  Interestingly, on the base of the Robin Hood figure are the words “Portrayed by Richard Green " - they made a great life-like plastic figure but couldn't spell his name properly!

 

A good source of information in regard to the Robin Hood Marx Playsets is contained in the Dec., 1994 edition - No. 34 - of the magazine " Plastic Figure and Playset Collector "

 

Ralph Cooper


 

That’s all folks

 

Our next issue is out on the 30th June 2004.  If you have any items of interest you wish included in the magazine please do not hesitate to contact us at trhas@hotmail.com.

 

Anna and Mike